Immigration and Naturalization Service v. Chadha

The Case: U.S. Supreme Court decision concerning the use of legislative vetoes on immigration rulings

Date: Decided on June 23, 1983

Significance: Based on the constitutional principles of separation of powers and bicameralism, the Chadha decision prohibited legislation authorizing one house of Congress fromoverriding a decision made by the executive branch.

One section of the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 authorized the attorney general to allow particular deportable aliens to remain in the United States, but the act also provided the option of a “legislative veto,” which authorized a single chamber of Congress to invalidate the decision of the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS). From 1932 until 1983, Congress included legislative vetoes in almost three hundred laws. The use of the procedure was considered an effective way of retaining legislative control over the president and regulations of the executive agencies.

Born in Kenya to Indian parents and holding a British passport, Jagdish Rai Chadha had studied in the United States with a student visa. When his visa expired, neither Great Britain nor Kenya would accept him, so he applied for permanent residence in the United States. Based on Chadha’s character and “extreme hardship,” the INS approved his application, but the House of Representatives voted to veto the decision.

By a 7-2 vote, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the U.S. Constitution did not authorize the use of the legislative veto. With this ruling, the Court struck down more congressional enactments than it had previously in its entire history. Speaking for the majority, Chief Justice Warren E. Burger wrote that “explicit and unambiguous provisions of the Constitution prescribe and define the respective functions of the Congress and of the Executive.” Any valid congressional mandate, he explained, must include passage by both houses of Congress, followed by presentment to the president, whose veto could be overridden only by a two-thirds vote in both houses. In a vigorous dissent, Justice Byron R. White argued that if Congress could delegate powers to the executive branch, it should be able to place limitations on these powers.

Thomas Tandy Lewis

Further Reading

  • Craig, Barbara H. Chadha: The Story of an Epic Constitutional Struggle. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1988. 
  • Maltz, Earl. Chief Justiceship of Warren Burger, 1969-1986. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 2000. 

See also: Citizenship; Congress, U.S.; Constitution, U.S.; Due process protections; Immigration law; Supreme Court, U.S.

Add comments

reload, if the code cannot be seen

Micheal Walter0 answers 12 July 2017 09:49 Quote

Hey guys, I'm so excited to share my TESTIMONY ON HOW Prophet EFE (GREAT SPELL CASTER) HELPED ME TO WIN A LOTTERY. I am Micheal . I won Euro Millions Millionaire Raffle prize of 1,000,000 on Dec 2016, I took an advice from a person who talked about this great spell caster on the internet, the person placed a testimony on a blog saying how this prophet helped him win the lottery by sending him the winning numbers , I was curious and I thought it was all joke not until I contacted this spell caster to know for myself how this works because I had spent alots buying tickets and I never won. I contacted him and he told me the necessary things needed to be done and I did just as he said and he told me to wait for just 3 days, on the 3rd day he gave me the winning numbers to play the lottery which i did, Can you believe my name was the first among winners. He told me my son all i need you to do for me is make sure that you share this testimony to others in need of help so that they can also win the lottery. I am sharing this testimony with everyone who needs help to win lottery. Contact this great prophet through his email address efepowerfultemple@gmail.com ,you can also call him or add him on whats-app: +2347081602438 .for any marital problems so he said.thank you Prophet Efe i own you my life.

illum77718 answers 23 July 2017 05:39 Quote

Welco­me to the great broth­erhoo­d of Illum­inati­: +2348­130184321 call DR GREG to join the Illum­inati broth­erhoo­d to get rich and famou­s, the
templ­e of Illum­inati world­wide.­Are you a polit­ician­, busin­ess man/w­oman ,
mu­sical artis­te, stude­nt, footb­aller or whate­ver occup­ation you do you
want to be rich, power­ful and famou­s in life.­Illum­inati can grant all your

hear­t desir­e join the Illum­inati to becom­e rich and famou­s in life,­
Ill­umina­ti we make you achie­ve your dream to becom­e rich and prote­ct you
all the days of your life.­.....­

B­ENEFI­T GIVEN TO A NEW MEMBE­R WHO JOIN THE ILLUM­INATI­

a cash rewar­d of usd $300,­000 usd
a new sleek dream car value­d at usd $120,­000 usd
a dream house bough­t in the count­ry of your own choic­e
on­e month holid­ay (full­y paid) to your dream touri­st
d­estin­ation­.
on­e year golf membe­rship packa­ge
a v.i.p treat­ment in all airpo­rts in the world­
a total lifes­tyle chang­e
ac­cess to bohem­ian grove­
mon­thly payme­nt of $1,00­0,000 usd into your bank accou­nt
e­very month as a membe­r,
o­ne month booke­d appoi­ntmen­t with top 5 world leade­rs
a­nd top 5 celeb­ritie­s in the world­>>


JOIN ILLUM­INATI YOUR FINAN­CIAL DIFFI­CULTI­ES ARE BROUG­HT TO AN END. WE
S­UPPOR­T YOU BOTH FINAN­CIALL­Y AND SPIRI­TUALL­Y TO ENSUR­E YOU LIVE A
CO­MFORT­ABLE LIFE.­IF YOU ARE INTER­ESTED CONTA­CT MR ANDY +2348130184321

OR Email us illum0325@gmai­l.com for immed­iatel­y
in­itiat­ion

A–Z index